James Hansen is a Climate Denier

You can't make things like this up. James Hansen, one of the most vocal proponents of global warming, is now part of the global warming denial campaign.

I would never have imagined that until I read an article about a new paper, Institutionalizing delay: foundation funding and the creation of U.S. climate change counter-movement organizations, by Robert Brulle. It claims to investigate the financial status of the "climate change counter-movement" (CCCM), also referred to as the "denial campaign." I was flabbergasted when I read this in its introduction:

What is the climate change counter-movement?
Here I argue that an efficacious approach to defining this movement is to view it as a cultural contestation between a social movement advocating restrictions on carbon emissions and a counter-movement opposed to such action.

According to this, it doesn't matter if you believe in global warming. It doesn't matter if you think global warming is a serious problem. It doesn't matter if you demand taxes on fossil fuels to pay for investments in renewable energy and carbon sequestering to attempt to lower carbon dioxide emissions. All that matters is how you feel about "restrictions on carbon emissions."

And it's not just bad wording. The Conclusion section of the paper says:

The CCCM efforts focus on maintaining a field frame that justifies unlimited use of fossil fuels by attempting to delegitmate the science that supports the necessity of mandatory limits on carbon emissions.

Mandatory limits/restrictions on carbon emissions are known as cap and trade. Oppose those, and no matter what else you may say or do, you're part of the "denial campaign." That means when James Hansen writes things like:

But at the heart of his plan is cap and trade, a market-based approach that has been widely praised but does little to slow global warming or reduce our dependence on fossil fuels. It merely allows polluters and Wall Street traders to fleece the public out of billions of dollars.
It is not too late to trade cap and trade for an approach that actually works.

He's part of the "denial campaign."

I'll leave it at that for today. There's a lot more wrong with the paper, but I can't stop laughing long enough to write it out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *