2012-02-09 15:42:25Inflammatory tone
John Cook

john@skepticalscience...
130.102.158.12

 

I thought this deleted comment was fairly gentle - is that considered inflammatory enough to warrant deletion?
Dale at 13:47 PM on 9 February 2012

skywatcher:
Yes I read the reviews *insert eyeroll here*. You highlight how one review compared Mann to a turd. Sorry, but I didn't see many positive reviews holding back against "deniers" either. Like I said, contaminated chest thumping by both "sides".

bill:
Scott Mandia's review goes into great details as to what the book is about. Mann tries to establish cred with the reader by explaining his start in science, then he tries to establish cred with the reader for his field, then he tries to justify his credibility, and then has a sob how he's been treated so badly.

Where's the actual SCIENCE?