2011-03-11 18:28:41Basic rebuttal No. 160 - Coral atolls grow as sea level rises
Rob Painting
Rob
paintingskeri@vodafone.co...
118.92.83.209

CORAL ATOLLS: THAT SINKING FEELING 

Coral atolls don't always keep grow well enough to keep in touch with sea level. The ocean is littered with thousands of former coral reefs and atolls which "drowned" when they failed to grow fast enough to match sea level. Being  generally less than 3 metres above sea level they are particularly vulnerable to sea level rise.

Recent work shows that people living on coral atolls in the Pacific will suffer once sea level rises above the solid reef foundations which formed during a period of locally higher sea level 4000 to 2000 years ago. Waves will begin to pound and erode the atolls long before they are submerged.

CORAL ATOLL FORMATION

Coral reefs grow only in warm waters of the world and form as generations of coral build upon the "bones of their ancestors". Given the right conditions coral are able grow fast enough to keep pace with moderate rates of sea level rise.

It was Charles Darwin whom first realized that coral atolls are the remains of submerged ocean volcanoes (Darwin 1942) with successive generations of coral growing on top of a slowly sinking volcano. This was later confirmed by deep drilling on coral atolls (Royal Society of London 1904, Ladd & Ingerson 1953)

We now know that sea level has fluctuated a lot during the Quaternary ice ages of the last few million years, so the process is more complex than Darwin suggested. Reef building on the atoll top has stopped when sea level fell and began growing again many thousands of years later when each ice age ended and sea level flooded the atoll top. The top 10 -15 metres of many atolls represent the "recent" growth during the current interglacial, the Holocene.

 

Figure 1. Atoll history through ice age sea level fluctuation. a) sea level thousands of years before & up to present. b) Atoll form relative to sea level. From Woodroffe 2007

A LONG HISTORY OF REEF DROWNING

Just like Goldilocks, coral reefs are very picky about environmental conditions. Growth can slow down when waters become too hot, too cool or too acidified (Flood 2001), (Scheibner & Speijer 2008).Guyots are drowned ancient coral atolls, and thousands of these lie beneath the Pacific sea surface.

Coral reef growth during the Holocene, like that of ancient reefs show evidence of having " temporarily drowned" at some point. Many regions also harbour relict reefs which have permanently drowned during the Holocene. One vast relict complex exists in deeper water off the Great Barrier Reef for example.  

HIGHER PACIFIC SEA LEVEL IN THE HOLOCENE

At around 8-9 thousands years ago sea level caught up with the tops of the eroded atolls and new Holocene reef growth began to be cemented over the older reef foundations. Sea level reached a highstand in the Pacific between 4-2000 years ago (Dickinson 2003, Woodroffe & McLean 1998). Coral reef tops grew to this higher sea level but were exposed once local sea level fell again, through ocean siphoning (Mitrovica & Milne 2002).

THE END OF ATOLL NATIONS

Now that global sea level is rising once more the solid foundations (reef flats) which support the stable Pacific atolls, will be overtopped by the sea at some point. Many of these are 0.5 to 1 metre above local high tide. Submerging these solid foundations will lead to the atolls being vulnerable to wave damage. Erosion will begin to sweep away the rubble, sediment and thin soils, making them uninhabitable at some point in the future. Dickinson 2009 estimates that by mid to late 21st century most atolls will be awash.

HOMELESS

Although they appear like permanent features, Pacific coral atolls have only existed for about two thousand years, and are stable because the solid foundations protect them from major erosion. This protection is only likely to continue until mid century for some atolls.

Atoll islanders may be hanging in there right now but eventually global warming, and the rising seas, will make them homeless.

2011-04-09 02:44:33
Daniel Bailey
Daniel Bailey
yooper49855@hotmail...
97.83.150.37

Looks good, like it.

 

Couple of nits:

You should probably explain your term "highstand" for the general reader.  Bit murky of a term for the average barmaid, but easily grasped once explained (and we like our barmaids grasping things).

You should spell out at some point that coral atolls in the Indian & Atlantic Oceans and the Caribbean Sea will be similarly affected.

2011-04-17 00:12:52
logicman

logicman_alf@yahoo.co...
86.145.235.170

Minor typo:

Given the right conditions coral are able grow fast enough

Given the right conditions corals are able to grow fast enough

 

Some points on the grammar.  ( If I don't nit pick, some denier will! )

It was Charles Darwin whom first realized

whom who

Use 'whom only after a preposition.

 

Reef building on the atoll top has stopped when sea level fell

 

Just like Goldilocks, coral reefs are very picky about environmental conditions.

Coral reefs are very picky about environmental conditions.

( 'Goldilocks' is meaningless to many cultures and their EFL students. )

 

Many regions also harbour relict reefs which have permanently drowned during the Holocene.

 

Suggested insert:

This protection is only likely to continue until mid century for some atolls.

 

Vulnerability to a storm surge or tsunami is greater as sea levels rise.  Atoll islanders may be hanging in there right now but ...