![]() | ||
2010-09-05 21:17:05 | Basic rebuttal 52: Pluto is warming | |
gpwayne Graham Wayne graham@gpwayne... 81.152.234.172 |
Argument 52: Pluto is warming The argument is this; other planets are warming. If this is happening throughout the solar system, clearly it must be the sun causing the rise in temperatures – including here on Earth.
Claims that solar system bodies are heating up due to increased solar activity are clearly wrong. The sun’s output has declined in recent decades. Only Pluto and Neptune are exhibiting increased brightness. Heating attributed to other solar bodies remains unproven. | |
2010-09-05 21:20:43 | Author's Note | |
gpwayne Graham Wayne graham@gpwayne... 81.152.234.172 |
Because there is so very little to say about individual planets, Iÿ've written one text and used it for the Jupiter, Neptune and Pluto basic rebuttals, changing the bullet point order so the specific planet is the first in the list depending on which argument you look up. This text in turn is taken from a slightly expanded version done for the ÿ'solar systemÿ' argument. Hope this is acceptible... (PS - Mars has a full rebuttal of its own) | |
2010-09-07 16:51:13 | Mention cooler sun. | |
villabolo villabolo@yahoo... 76.93.65.8 |
Good idea on lumping all the individual planets into one rebuttal. You could mention that the sun has actually cooled off. Further, the sun goes through regular cycles of cooling and warming which do not match the warming up of any planet. VILLABOLO | |
2010-09-08 00:04:22 | Basic Rebuttal 52: thumbs up | |
jimalakirti jimalakirti@gmail... 70.56.240.163 |
 Please change: "the sunÿ's output" to "the sun's output" "heating attributed to other solar bodies are unproven" to "heating attributed to other solar bodies is unproven" | |
2010-09-09 01:40:49 | ||
doug_bostrom dbostrom@clearwire... 184.77.83.151 |
All planets are green... | |
2010-09-09 04:08:16 | OK | |
nealjking nealjking@gmail... 84.151.34.204 |
Approve it | |
2010-09-09 15:43:40 | Just fine. | |
villabolo villabolo@yahoo... 76.93.65.8 |
You might (quibble, quibble) set the planets in order of distance from the sun. Mars, Jupiter, Neptune and Pluto. VILLABOLO | |
2010-09-10 19:58:27 | ||
Rob Painting Rob paintingskeri@vodafone.co... 118.93.210.213 |
Another thumbs up. | |
2010-09-10 22:45:03 | thanks | |
gpwayne Graham Wayne graham@gpwayne... 86.158.204.104 |
Thanks everyone. I'm going to accumulate all the corrections in one go and update all the versions. The order (Villabolo) is dictated by which rebuttal you go to - i.e. the list always starts with the planet named in the specific rebuttal. | |
2010-09-11 00:12:24 | Revision done | |
gpwayne Graham Wayne graham@gpwayne... 86.158.204.104 |
OK - I've updated all these rebuttals, but they are all identical now. Could you please comment only on the post Basic rebuttal 25: Other planets in the solar system are warming - just to keept things all in one place. |