Skeptical Science Forum


2010-09-21 13:41:45	Can anyone help me with this data? Mann vs Wahl hockey stick
John Cook john@skepticalscience... 121.222.93.62	I need to replot the data in the following graph: I don't suppose anyone already has their hands on the data? Eg - Mann's hockey stick + Wahl's hockey stick? Or even better, already have the data in Excel? Just asking in case someone might have the data handy.
2010-09-22 11:49:56	Found better version of the graph but still looking for the data
John Cook john@skepticalscience... 121.222.93.62	Someone emailed me this smoothed version which is much easier to look at: Still, if anyone does have this data (particularly the smoothed version) lying around under a pile of notes, please sing out :-)
2010-09-23 00:22:11	comment
Robert Way robert_way19@hotmail... 134.153.10.5	Mann 1999 ftp://ftp.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/paleo/contributions_by_author/mann1999/recons/nhem-recon.dat Wahl and Amman 2007 is here ftp://ftp.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/paleo/contributions_by_author/ammann2007/ammann2007.txt not sure if they have different baselines. Not sure though...
2010-09-23 09:46:57	Thanks heaps Robert
John Cook john@skepticalscience... 121.222.93.62	Appreciate the link. Been meaning for ages to get the data on Mann's hockey stick :-)
2010-09-25 10:04:14	Comment
Robert Way robert_way19@hotmail... 142.162.201.109	http://pubs.giss.nasa.gov/docs/notyet/inpress_Schmidt_etal_2.pdf http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~tingley/Blakeley_Discussion_Tingley_LongVersion.pdf This outta deal with that mcshane and wyner stuff...
2010-09-25 11:03:40	Thanks for the heads up re the comments on McShane
John Cook john@skepticalscience... 124.185.151.34	Is it appropriate to do a post about these yet? Or should we wait till they're published?
2010-09-26 04:06:39	Comment
Robert Way robert_way19@hotmail... 142.162.201.109	Mcintyre has a comment too. Haven't seen it yet. i'd wait till we do... I might consider tackling this one when it comes